Direct Cremation: how to make an informed choice

St Marylebone Crematorium in North London

Direct Cremation is becoming an increasingly popular choice for people arranging a funeral. It’s been promoted as an affordable, simple and no fuss option. Sounds good, right? However, not everyone realises what a Direct Cremation involves and it might not be the right choice after all! In this blogpost I discuss pros and cons of Direct Cremation. I hope it helps people who are planning or arranging a funeral make a more informed decision.

What is a Direct Cremation?

First things first: what is a Direct Cremation? At a Direct Cremation, there is no funeral service. This means that people can save on a lot of costs involved in arranging a funeral including funeral director and officiant fees, flowers, order of services, limousines, chapel hire and catering expenses.

Direct Cremations got a boost in the pandemic. During the lockdowns, funeral services were restricted or not possible at all. People chose alternative ways to honour the life of their person, for example by having a funeral ceremony online or organising a gathering at a later date. According to the SunLife Cost of Dying Report 2023, there has been a sustained rise in Direct Cremations. in 2019, 3% of all funerals were Direct Cremations, in 2021 and 2022 this had increased to 18%. And awareness of Direct Cremation during this time has grown from 52% to 71%.

Direct Cremations: pros

Let’s take a closer look at this funeral option. Why do people opt for a Direct Cremation? Here are some reasons, as expressed by people I have met and mentioned in research by the University of Bath:

  • Costs
  • The person who has died wanted a Direct Cremation
  • A feeling that arranging a funeral is to overwhelming
  • No need or wish for a funeral service (memories are more important than disposal of remains)
  • A negative experience with funerals as sombre, templated events that don’t feel right
  • Wish to find alternatives to traditional funerals
  • Control over who is attending (a funeral is a public social event)
  • A preference for a memorial service that can be held at an alternative venue to celebrate the person’s life

A Direct Cremation gives people the freedom to organise a celebration of life in a way that feels right for them. Some organise a gathering when the ashes are being scattered or interred, or they have a memorial service where they ask family and friends to share stories and memories, followed by a reception.

A Direct Cremation can be the right choice for people who don’t want a funeral service, for the reasons listen above, or others.

Direct Cremations: cons

When considering a Direct Cremation it is important to realise that it does not allow you to care for your person or say your farewells after your person has been taken into the funeral director’s care. For example, you can’t visit them to spend time with them as say your farewells. You can’t choose the clothes they wear, or the coffin they wll be resting in. You can’t choose the date and time of the cremation and no one is allowed to come to the crematorium on the day.

This can be really tough. A funeral, no matter how simple or small, is an opportunity to come together to pay a final respect to the person who has died. To accompany them as they leave this world. A funeral offers a space to share grief, friendship and love. The service does not have to be sombre or following a template or traditions that don’t resonate. It can be a unique, personalised event that can offer moments of beauty, gratitude and solace in difficult times.

I have met people who regret having opted for a Direct Cremation. Some responses:

“It was Mum’s wish to have a Direct Cremation, and we wanted to honour that, but something felt unfinished”.

“My experience of funerals have been quite awful and I did not want that for my brother so we chose for a Direct Cremation. However, when I attended my Uncle’s non-religious funeral recently I was positively surprised by how uplifting the service was. It felt he was in the room with us. I now wish we had organised a service for my brother also.”

If you want a Direct Cremation for yourself, discuss this wish with your people as it may be that they need or wish something else after you have died. An open conversation about your wishes, the reasons behind them and the concerns and ideas of your family and friends will help plan for your ending in a way that feels right for all.

The purpose of a funeral

A Direct Cremation focuses on the disposal of the body. It reduces a funeral to a practical, technical exercise. It strips the funeral from all its ritual: the rituals of washing and dressing your person, choosing and decorating their coffin, spending time with them after they have died, crafting a service that honours their life and how they have made a difference to the people around them, carrying the coffin, saying a final goodbye before they depart to the realm of the dead whereas you make your way back into the world of the living.

A funeral can be a healing experience and help in your grief journey. In the end, a funeral is aimed at the living, giving them the opportunity to do what they want and need to do to express their grief, pay tribute to their person and find moments of comfort and hope for the time to come.

Stripping funerals from ritual deprives the bereaved from an opportunity to share grief and joy as part of a wider community. And although a memorial service can achieve a similar goal, I believe that it makes a difference when the dead are still present in their bodily form. A funeral is a life-defining threshold moment. We enter the funeral space together with the dead, and leave the space without them.

Cost considerations aside, Direct Cremations fit into an approach of funeral as private, individualised events where celebrating a life in a unique, personalised way overtakes community mourning rituals. Although we honour the dead, we don’t feel comfortable in their presence and rather focus on their life. I find this a fascinating development and wonder how this affects the way we grieve and deal with our own mortality in the longer term.

Balancing costs and meaning

To those of you who do want a funeral but are concerned about costs, I hear you. Funerals are expensive and Direct Cremations have their place in a world where many people struggle to make ends meet. But there are options to personalise a funeral and include rituals that don’t cost the earth. A few thoughts:

  • If you opt for a Direct Cremation you can care for your person and say your farewells before they have been taken into care by a funeral director. A celebrant, end-of-life doula or funeral director specialised in home funerals can give you advice and help you.
  • You can create your own rituals or ceremony following the cremation. A celebrant can help you or hold the space for you and those attending.
  • There are different types of funeral directors. Some offer flexible options, even if you choose for a Direct Cremation. Shop around and ask about their services. The Good Funeral Guide has a comprehensive list of recommended independent funeral directors who are willing to listen to your wishes and work with your budget and needs.
  • Find ways to save on funeral costs. Use your own transport, hire a coffin, leave out the order of service or create one yourself. Pick flowers from your garden or buy them in the supermarket. For more ideas, check out my blog on how to save funeral costs.

Direct Cremation: would it be your choice?

What are your thoughts on Direct Cremation? Do you have experience with this funeral option or is this something you would consider? Leave your comments below, I’d love to hear your thoughts. And if you have any questions about how I as a celebrant can help you with your end-of-life or funeral planning, do get in touch!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.